Loading...
First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides scores 8.5/9.8 and fresh Umbrian Clay Pore Purifying Face Mask scores 8.3/9.8 — a near-tie where your skin type decides the winner.
These two are neck and neck — just 0.2 points apart.
Scores last verified: June 2026
39 unique
17 in common
26 unique
These two eye-cares take different paths to a similar destination. Both formulas include solid hydrating ingredients, and the overall scores reflect that — the gap here is genuinely slim.
Formulation Safety is another area of separation. First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides scores 9.0 here versus 8.7 for fresh Umbrian Clay Pore Purifying Face Mask. That difference comes down to how each formula is built — the ingredient list tells the story.
First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides brings Saccharomyces Ferment, Retinol, and Caffeine as actives, while fresh Umbrian Clay Pore Purifying Face Mask relies on Saccharomyces/Xylinum/Black Tea Ferment, Acetyl Dipeptide-1 Cetyl Ester, and Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract. Both approaches have merit, but the positioning and supporting ingredients make the difference.
First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides is better if you have
fresh Umbrian Clay Pore Purifying Face Mask is better if you have
Both sit in the premium bracket, so value comes down to formulation quality. First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides gets the nod here with its 8.5 overall score — you're getting more for a similar outlay.
It's a close call — both products score within 0.3 points of each other. Your choice depends on your specific skin concerns.
Based on ingredient analysis, First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Retinol Eye Cream with Retinol, Squalane + Ceramides scores higher overall. See the full score breakdown above for details on each attribute.
Yes, they share common ingredients. Check the ingredient face-off section above for a detailed comparison.
The key differences are in their active ingredients and formulation approach. Check the attribute battle above for a detailed breakdown.
Some links on this site are affiliate links. We may earn a commission from purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep Gracie free and independent.
© 2026 Gracie. All rights reserved. Data sourced from Open Beauty Facts (ODbL) and EU CosIng.