✶

Aquaphor Lip Repair vs Kiehl's Since 1851 B… — Which Is Better? | Gracie

Products
Ingredients
Brands
K-Beauty
Blog
How We Score

Gracie
/Compare
/Aquaphor Lip Repair
/vs
/Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment

Aquaphor Lip Repair vs Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment

Aquaphor Lip Repair scores 7.0/9.8 vs Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment at 5.9/9.8. Aquaphor Lip Repair wins for hydration.

Head to head

Aquaphor

Lip Repair

lip-care

7.0

Buy at Amazon

Compare

Best Moisturisers
Best Serums
Best Cleansers
Best SPF

Ingredients

Niacinamide
Retinol
Hyaluronic Acid
Salicylic Acid

K-Beauty

K-Beauty Hub
K-Beauty Moisturisers
K-Beauty Serums
K-Beauty Sunscreens

About

Methodology
About Us
All Brands
All Products

Gracie

Honest skincare intel. No jargon, no gatekeeping — just the ingredients decoded.

Kiehl's Since 1851

Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment

lip-caremid-range

5.9

Score comparison

Aquaphor Lip Repair takes this one, winning 2 of 5 attributes.

Aquaphor wins 2

Tied 3

Kiehl's Since 1851 wins 0

7.0Aquaphor

+1.1vs

5.9Kiehl's Since 1851

Scores last verified: June 2026

Attribute battle

Hydration Efficacy

Aquaphor WINS

6.6

2.6

Aquaphor

Kiehl's Since 1851

Irritation Risk

TIE

9.5

Aquaphor

Kiehl's Since 1851

Active Ingredient Strength

Aquaphor WINS

2.4

2.0

Aquaphor

Kiehl's Since 1851

Ingredient Transparency

TIE

7.5

Aquaphor

Kiehl's Since 1851

Formulation Safety

TIE

9.0

Aquaphor

Kiehl's Since 1851

Ingredient face-off

21% overlap

19Aquaphor

4Shared

19Kiehl's Since 1851

Only in Aquaphor Lip Repair

15 unique

C18-38 Alkyl Hydroxystearoyl Stearate Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil Glycerin Panthenol Water Polyglyceryl-3 Diisostearate Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea Butter)Hydrogenated Castor Oil C20-40 Alkyl Stearate Acetate+5 more

Shared ingredients

4 in common

Octyldodecanol Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride Bis-Diglyceryl Polyacyladipate-2 Tocopherol

Only in Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment

15 unique

Cocos Nucifera Oil / Coconut Oil Cera Alba / Beeswax / Cire Dabeille Ricinus Communis Seed Oil / Castor Seed Oil Jojoba Esters Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oil / Jojoba Seed Oil Helianthus Annuus Seed Cera / Sunflower Seed Wax Irvingia Gabonensis Kernel Butter Aqua / Water / Eau

Why Aquaphor Lip Repair comes out ahead

Where Aquaphor Lip Repair really shines is hydration efficacy, scoring 6.6 compared to Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment's 2.6. With Glycerin, Panthenol, and Beeswax in its top ingredients, Aquaphor Lip Repair delivers stronger moisture-binding capability.

Active Ingredient Strength is another area of separation. Aquaphor Lip Repair scores 2.4 here versus 2.0 for Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment. That difference comes down to how each formula is built — the ingredient list tells the story.

Aquaphor Lip Repair brings Tocopherol, Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate, and Bisabolol as actives, while kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment relies on Tocopherol, Vanilla Planifolia Fruit Extract, and Stevia Rebaudiana Leaf/Stem Extract. Both approaches have merit, but the positioning and supporting ingredients make the difference.

Best for your skin type

Aquaphor Lip Repair is better if you have

Sensitive skin — the low-irritation formula keeps things gentle
Anyone who prefers clean, well-vetted formulations

Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment is better if you have

Sensitive skin — the low-irritation formula keeps things gentle
Anyone who prefers clean, well-vetted formulations

Value comparison

Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment comes in at mid-range pricing with a 5.9 score, which is reasonable for what you get.

Our verdict

✶ Our verdict

+1.1 lead

Aquaphor Lip Repair wins this comparison with a meaningfully stronger ingredient profile and overall score.

7.0Aquaphor

5.9Kiehl's Since 1851

Frequently asked questions

Which is better: Aquaphor Lip Repair or Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment?

Based on ingredient analysis, Aquaphor Lip Repair scores higher overall. See the full score breakdown above for details on each attribute.

Do Aquaphor Lip Repair and Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment share ingredients?

Yes, they share common ingredients. Check the ingredient face-off section above for a detailed comparison.

What's the main difference between Aquaphor Lip Repair and Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment?

The key differences are in their active ingredients and formulation approach. Check the attribute battle above for a detailed breakdown.

Full analysis: Aquaphor Lip Repair→Full analysis: Kiehl's Since 1851 Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment→

We may earn a commission from purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep Gracie free and independent.

Some links on this site are affiliate links. We may earn a commission from purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep Gracie free and independent.

Hydrogenated Coco-Glycerides

Acacia Decurrens Flower Cera / Acacia Decurrens Flower Wax

+5 more